L-Rodd,
You don't seem argumentative at all.
Here's my stance on salmon:
I don't agree with recommendations to eat salmon because I'm a vegetarian. I don't believe it is EVER necessary for humans to eat meat to acquire the nutrients they need.
One thing I like about the article you linked is their explanation as to WHY salmon is frequently recommended. The only benefit from salmon (and a few other fish) is their concentration of Omega 3 fatty acids. These acids are not produced by the fish; the fish acquire them through eating sea algae (a plant). So, the highly touted Omega 3 acids are actually a plant-based nutrient. It's just more common for people to consume them through the second-hand source of the fish. It seems to me it would be much more efficient (and humane) to harvest and consume these acids from their source, a sea plant, rather than from an animal.
Some cultures do eat seaweed and algae, but it's unrealistic to expect Americans to do so! The only Omega acid supplements I've seen are derived from fish oil, but I'd assume it would also be possible for scientists to produce supplements directly from sea algae. I don't know why they are not currently doing this; probably complacency...it's just easier to exploit fish.
The whole subject of essential fatty acids is interesting because it's more complex than most people know. Here are a few webpages I found about this. These discuss the different kinds of Omega 3 acids (ALA, EPA, DHA) and Omega 6 acids.
I follow the principle that consuming plant-based ALA acids is enough, since the body converts them to the other forms.
wholehealthmd.comhealthy adviceWhat's a Vegetarian to Do?One question I formed from reading your article is: where do most of the salmon Americans eat come from? The article stated salmon that are free to roam the ocean acquire high amounts of Omega acids, but does this describe what most people are eating? I've heard of salmon farming where the fish are kept contained in nets. Are farmed fish as high in this nutrient? If they aren't, and if farmed fish are what most people eat, then people may not be deriving as much benefit as they believe. I don't expect you to research this for me; your article was just thought-provoking!
